041 Commentary

From Faith Futures
Jump to: navigation, search

This page forms part of the resources for 041 Trees and Hearts in the Jesus Database project of FaithFutures Foundation

Crossan Inventory | 041 Literature | 041 Parallels | 041 Commentary | 041 Poetry | 041 Images


Commentary

Jesus Seminar

The views of the Seminar on this item can be represented as follows:

Thom 45:1a

Thom 45:1b
Thom 45:2-3
Thom 45:4
Luke 6:43
Luke 6:44a
Luke 6:44b
Luke 6:45a
Luke 6:45b
Matt 7:16a
Matt 7:16b
Matt 7:17-18
Matt 7:19
Matt 7:20
Matt 12:33a
Matt 12:33b
Matt 12:34
Matt 12:35
IgnEph 14:2b

The Seminar (which used the name "By Their Fruits" for this cluster), took the various elements of this saying separately. The commentary in [The Five Gospels] (298f) notes that, apart from "the quip about thorns and brambles in v. 44b," most of the sayings in the cluster belong to everyday proverbial wisdom. While Jesus doubtless drew on conventional and traditional materials, his distinctive insights into the sacred depths of everyday life are best observed in the aphorisms and parables that have no parallels.


Lüdemann

Gerd Lüdemann [Jesus] (300f) suggests that Luke has adapted a Q parable (found in a more original form in Matt 7:16-18) by intentionally folding into this section other Q material (Matt 12:34b) to fashion a brief integrated saying around this theme.